Shown here are #211 J.W. Porter, #212 Jack Dittmer, #225 Bobby Shantz, and #231 Solly Hemus. Yes, the Porter actually is that beat up. When I sent it to him, he felt so bad about its condition that he also included a signed reprint card of his. With the exception of Dittmer, these were all obtained TTM, and without fees. I mentioned earlier that Shantz was coming off an MVP season; that year he went 24-7 with a 2.48 ERA for the Mackmen, who finished 4th, 16 games out. That crease in the scan is on the penny sleeve, not the actual card.